California's Eviction Crisis: Proposed Legislation Aims to Protect Tenants from Nonpayment Evictions

In California, a couple struggling with health issues faced eviction from their subsidized home despite having the funds to settle their unpaid rent. 

Currently, state law allows landlords to evict renters for not paying on time, without considering whether they can catch up on late payments. However, there's a push for a new rule to stop this practice, aiming to match the policies of 21 other states that protect tenants willing to pay their due rent.

Bradford Berger and his wife, facing eviction in San Francisco, are just one example of many who find themselves in this difficult situation. Despite the offer of rental assistance that covers late payments, their landlord chose to proceed with the eviction process. 

This situation showcases a gap in the system where rental aid doesn't always prevent eviction.

Landlords argue that the proposed law is not needed, stating that tenants can seek legal ways to buy more time if they're having money problems. Groups advocating for landlords have strongly opposed the bill, highlighted by the California Apartment Association.

Evidently, the issue worsened after COVID-19 restrictions were relaxed. For instance, in Los Angeles, nearly all eviction notices in a certain period were for not paying rent. Similarly, in San Mateo County, unpaid rent was the leading cause of evictions.

Though data on evictions due to nonpayment is hard to track due to court confidentiality, what's clear is that rental help programs have grown in cities and counties, aiming to assist tenants during temporary financial troubles. 

However, the process isn’t smooth, and it typically takes about three months for rental assistance to reach landlords, often too late for tenants who have a short time to respond to eviction notices.

Proposed legislation is aiming to create a "right to repair," allowing tenants to avoid eviction by paying owed rent at any point until their actual removal. Landlords sometimes work with tenants on payment plans, but tenant lawyers report instances of payments being refused leading up to an eviction, citing discrimination concerns.

Landlords, though, argue that letting tenants delay payment until eviction looms erodes the importance of paying rent on time. The new bill wants to grant tenants the opportunity to settle their debts and avoid eviction, similar to what homeowners get when they fall behind on mortgage payments.

The struggle against eviction is complex and often filled with tough life events that harm low-income individuals the most. The story of the Bergers, who fell behind on rent due to medical and financial setbacks, exemplifies the need for better solutions. 

Despite rental assistance approval and an appeal for understanding due to severe illness, their landlord opted for eviction.

This unfolding drama reflects a broader debate about fairness and assistance in housing, balancing the rights of tenants to maintain their homes against the rights of landlords to manage their properties. 

The outcome of the pending bill will significantly impact how nonpayment eviction cases are handled in California in the future.

Check out: What to Do When Facing Eviction: Helpful Tips and Solutions

-

Previous article: Help for First-Time Homebuyers in New Mexico